Oh Shirt Yeah vs RushOrderTees: Which Screen Printer Delivers?

RushOrderTees (operated by Printfly) is one of the larger online screen printing companies in the US, processing thousands of orders from their Philadelphia facility. Oh Shirt Yeah is a woman-owned print shop in Vacaville, California with in-house production and warehouse fulfillment. Both do real screen printing — but the experience and outcomes are quite different.

Company Overview

Print Quality

Both companies do actual screen printing, which puts them ahead of DTG-only platforms like Vistaprint. The difference comes down to scale and quality control.

Oh Shirt Yeah produces everything in-house at their Vacaville facility with direct oversight on every order. Their 4.9-star rating across 80+ reviews suggests very consistent output.

RushOrderTees operates at much higher volume from their Philadelphia production facility. While many customers report good results, there's a consistent thread of complaints about print placement — logos arriving crooked, off-center, or at different positions on different shirts in the same order.

Winner: Oh Shirt Yeah — Smaller volume means tighter quality control. RushOrderTees' scale introduces consistency risks.

Pricing

RushOrderTees has an instant online pricing tool — enter your quantity, colors, and garment, and you get a price immediately. This is convenient and transparent. However, multiple reviewers describe them as "a bit pricier compared to others."

Oh Shirt Yeah provides custom quotes within 1-2 business days. For comparable orders (24+ shirts, 1-3 colors), their pricing is competitive and often lower because there's no platform overhead or technology markup built into the price.

RushOrderTees also has a no-refund policy that catches many customers off guard — if the print quality is poor, getting your money back can be a significant battle.

Winner: RushOrderTees for instant quotes | Oh Shirt Yeah for overall value

Turnaround Time

RushOrderTees markets speed as their core value — it's literally in the name. They offer standard, priority, rush, and super rush shipping options.

However, the "rush" promise doesn't always hold. Multiple reviews describe orders stuck in production past their guaranteed delivery dates, with tracking showing labels created but packages not actually shipped.

Oh Shirt Yeah offers standard (2 weeks), rush (1 week), and super rush (3-5 days). Because they control production in-house with a smaller order volume, timelines are more predictable. When they say two weeks, it's two weeks.

Winner: Oh Shirt Yeah — Reliable timelines beat a "rush" brand name that doesn't always deliver.

Customer Reviews

RushOrderTees has more total reviews because of their volume, and many are positive — particularly on platforms where they solicit reviews from satisfied customers. But when you look at unsolicited complaint platforms (ComplaintsBoard, BBB), a pattern emerges: print placement issues, sizing discrepancies, and difficulty getting refunds.

Oh Shirt Yeah's reviews are smaller in number but remarkably consistent — 4.9 stars with almost zero negative feedback across platforms.

Winner: Oh Shirt Yeah — Near-perfect consistency vs. high volume with notable complaint patterns.

Fulfillment & Storage

RushOrderTees is a print-and-ship operation. They produce your order and ship it to you. There's no option for warehouse storage, inventory management, or on-demand fulfillment.

Oh Shirt Yeah operates a warehouse in Vacaville, California. They produce your merch, store it, and ship orders on demand. For brands, businesses, and organizations with ongoing apparel needs, this transforms the relationship from a transaction into a partnership.

If you need to reorder from RushOrderTees, you go through the online process again. With Oh Shirt Yeah, your screens, files, and specs are on file — a reorder is a phone call.

Winner: Oh Shirt Yeah — Full fulfillment infrastructure vs. print-and-ship only.

Customer Service

RushOrderTees offers live chat, phone support, and email. Many customers praise specific representatives by name, which suggests some genuinely good people on their team. However, the experience is inconsistent — other customers report being given conflicting information by different reps and difficulty escalating issues.

Oh Shirt Yeah is a small team where you talk to the same people every time. The owner, Jordan, is directly involved. There's no call center, no ticket queue — just a real person who knows your order.

Winner: Oh Shirt Yeah — Direct relationship with the people making your shirts vs. call center lottery.

The Verdict

Choose RushOrderTees if:

• You want to design and price everything online without talking to anyone
• You need a large-scale platform with high-volume capacity
• The online design tool is important to your workflow

Choose Oh Shirt Yeah if:

• Print quality and placement consistency are critical
• You want warehouse storage and on-demand fulfillment
• You value a direct relationship with your printer
• You're building an ongoing merch or uniform program
• You want a guaranteed refund policy if something goes wrong
• You're in California or want to support a woman-owned small business

About This Comparison

This comparison is based on publicly available review data from Trustpilot, SmartCustomer, ComplaintsBoard, BBB, Yelp, and Google Reviews, as well as information published on ohshirtyeah.com and rushordertees.com. Review data was collected in March 2026. Learn more about our methodology.

Related comparisons: Oh Shirt Yeah vs Custom Ink · Oh Shirt Yeah vs Vistaprint